Pluribus and the Leadership Efficiency Trap, What is the Goal in Your AI Journey? & The One System Every Leader Depends On But Rarely Manages
15 December 2025 Newsletter
“Mediocre people cannot stand high achievers, and high achievers cannot stand mediocre people. You’ll never have team chemistry. Because everybody is not bought into the same principles, values and standard.” Nick Saban
Hope you’re Thriving!
It’s been a great week with a couple of workshops and a lot of meetings.
I thought I’d share the agenda from an annual strategic planning workshop last week. How are you maximising the time with your leadership team to build cohesion – outside the strategy planning work?
Wednesday:
- 2pm – 3 hour Drive to Dunsborough
- 530pm 1hr of Sauna / Icebath swapping
- 7pm swim at Idjinup spa
- Lamonts for dinner
- Staying at Smiths beach resort
Thursday:
- 530am – Swim at Yallingup
- 7am breakfast at Sora at 7am
- Workshop at Bunker Bay resort
- 6pm hike from Smiths to swim at Yallinup Aquarium
- Dinner at Miki’s Open Kitchen, Margaret River
Friday:
- 530am – Yoga
- Breakfast at Bunker Bay
- Ocean swim during the lunchtime break
- 530pm leave Dunsborough
- 3hrs of Brutal Facts on the way home
Lets jump in.
Pluribus and the Leadership Efficiency Trap
Apple TV’s Pluribus presents itself as a sci fi thriller, but beneath the storytelling sits a warning every business leader should pay attention to. A strange effect sweeps through the population, linking people into a shared consciousness that removes tension, disagreement and hesitation. Productivity increases. Harmony rises. Decision making becomes effortless.
And yet, one thing becomes obvious as the world slips into this state.
They are also creatively dead.
The infected have traded struggle for smoothness.
And struggle, uncomfortable as it is, happens to be the engine of better thinking.
Carol Sturka, one of the few who remains outside the hive mind, sees the cost immediately. The world has not become smarter. It has simply become frictionless. And frictionless feels good right up until the moment it destroys your ability to think independently.
This is the antagonist leaders need to recognise.
Not AI itself.
The removal of productive friction caused by AI driven efficiency.
The Optimisation Trap
Leaders are wired to eliminate inefficiency. They streamline processes, reduce variation and build systems that remove friction wherever possible. AI amplifies this instinct. With one prompt, leaders can generate strategy drafts, refine ideas and remove uncertainty long before their teams have wrestled with the problem.
McKinsey estimates generative AI could add trillions to global productivity, and it is easy to see why. Coding is faster. Communication is smoother. Alignment appears easier. But as efficiency increases, something else diminishes. The struggle that produces judgment.
A leadership team that adopts easy answers loses the ability to form strong ones.
When the edges disappear, so does the insight.
Carol’s world becomes optimised, but brittle. Many businesses are heading in the same direction.
The Death of Friction is the Death of Strategy
In Pluribus, once people join the hive mind, they stop needing to make decisions. Their preferences are predicted and met before conscious thought even forms. It looks efficient, but it removes the struggle that agency depends on.
That future is not as fictional as it seems.
We now live in a world where AI can forecast customer behaviour, simulate competitive responses and optimise supply chains with an accuracy no leadership team can match. If an AI system can execute strategy faster and more reliably than you, your success may be guaranteed, but your relevance is zero.
Harari has warned that when external systems know us better than we know ourselves, free will starts to feel optional. The risk for leaders is not losing control to technology. It is losing the habit of thinking altogether.
If AI solves every problem before it hurts, your team never develops the cognitive struggle required to build resilience. They never sit in uncertainty. They never push through ambiguity. They never learn to hold two competing ideas long enough to find the right answer.
You do not get a stronger company.
You get a brittle one.
A company that looks aligned, but collapses under pressure because it has forgotten how to think for itself.
The Creativity Crisis
The most unsettling part of Pluribus is not the hive mind. It is the outcome. The art, ideas and decisions produced by the infected are clean, structured and instantly coherent, yet they lack the imperfect edges that define real creativity.
Wharton professor Ethan Mollick calls this the jagged frontier. AI lifts the floor of competence but risks lowering the ceiling of originality by smoothing the unresolved edges where insight lives.
Creativity is inefficient by nature.
It demands wrong turns, slow debate and uncomfortable conversations.
It needs space to wrestle with complexity.
Remove that, and you get faster output, not better ideas. A leadership team that avoids discomfort does not innovate. It only produces polished versions of its existing thinking.
The danger is not mediocrity.
The danger is confident mediocrity.
The CEO’s Playbook: Managing the Smoothness
So what should leaders do in a world that rewards ease and speed?
The answer is not to resist AI, but to resist the temptation to eliminate the struggle that builds strength.
Preserve the valuable friction
The best conversations in leadership are often the slow, uncomfortable ones. Strategic debate, creative tension and real accountability should never be outsourced to an algorithm. If a meeting feels too easy, the thinking is probably too shallow.
Protect the outlier
Every organisation has someone who sees what others do not. In Pluribus, that person is Carol Sturka. In a business, it is usually the person who questions, hesitates or pushes back. They are not slowing you down. They are protecting your blind side.
Define better, not just faster
AI makes average work move quickly. Leaders must decide whether they want speed or depth. Depth always requires friction.
Watch for the moment the room becomes too calm
A team that stops disagreeing is not aligned.
It is absorbed.
The Real Lesson of Pluribus
Carol is not fighting to stay miserable. She is fighting to stay capable. She understands that the discomfort of thinking is not a flaw to be engineered away, but a requirement for staying human.
The same is true for leadership.
A company that avoids struggle avoids strength.
A team that avoids friction avoids insight.
A leader who removes tension removes the very thing that keeps the organisation from drifting.
The threat is not AI.
It is the comfort that makes you believe you no longer need to think.
That is the Pluribus warning.
Ignore it, and your company becomes peaceful, efficient and quietly defenceless.
What is the Goal in Your AI Journey?
This week I’ve been thinking about where most owners find themselves in their AI journey. The early excitement has passed. The novelty has worn off. The experiments were interesting, but now the real question sits quietly in front of you.
What is the goal, and where are you heading?
When you look at the classic exponential curve, we are standing at that deceptive point where progress feels slow. It still looks linear. It still feels manageable. Yet the steep part of the curve is just ahead, the part where companies either step into chaos or step into clarity. That small black dot labelled “you are here” is a reminder that the window for thoughtful decisions is still open, but narrowing.
In Made to Thrive, I wrote about understanding what it takes to succeed in a role. That same idea applies to your AI journey. You may be capable, and you may want the benefits that AI promises, but do you understand what success looks like for your business? Without that clarity, the work becomes reactive, and the drift begins.
For many Owner Led Companies, those first experiments created a sense of possibility. Now comes the harder shift, the move from curiosity to structured execution. This is where you pause and define your destination. Are you aiming to lower labour cost? Improve customer experience? Free leadership time? Build a more resilient system that can scale without stretching? Or simply ensure your business remains relevant as the curve steepens?
Before the acceleration comes, it may help to sit with a few questions.
- What specific outcome am I actually trying to achieve with AI, and would my team describe it the same way?
- If the exponential curve accelerates tomorrow, what would I wish I had already put in place?
- Which parts of my business genuinely need AI, and which parts only feel urgent because others are talking about them?
- How will I know that my AI efforts are making the business better rather than simply adding activity?
- What would a disciplined, well defined AI destination look like for an Owner Led Company like mine?
There is no single right answer to any of these. But there must be an answer.
AI without a defined goal becomes noise. You keep adding tools, but nothing compounds. You stay busy, but nothing really changes. In Bigger isn’t Better, Better is Better, I talk about the danger of chasing growth for its own sake. The same mindset applies here. More AI is not the goal. A better business is the goal.
So perhaps the real question for you is this. As the curve turns upward, what outcome are you deliberately building toward? And if you looked honestly at your current efforts, are they taking you there or simply filling time?
We are still at the point on the curve where reflection is possible and course correction is easy. Soon, the pace will quicken. The companies that thrive will be the ones that knew their destination before the acceleration began.
A better AI journey begins the same way a better business does, with clarity of purpose rather than the pursuit of more.
The One System Every Leader Depends On but Rarely Manages
This week I spoke with Dr Peter Larkins about something leaders hardly ever think about with structure. Their own capacity.
Every CEO has dashboards for margins, cash, customers and people. They watch the indicators. They run the rhythms. They try to get ahead of problems before they become expensive. Yet when it comes to their own body, the most important system in the business, the default setting is hope.
Hope that energy will stay high.
Hope that recovery will stay quick.
Hope that ageing will be gentle.
But hope is not a strategy, and age does not care that you are busy.
Peter sees this firsthand. His consulting rooms are filled with executives who have built careers on discipline and planning, yet never applied that same level of intention to the one thing they cannot outsource. Their long term health span. They arrive when the decline is already noticeable. They feel flat after travel. They take longer to bounce back from pressure. They sleep enough hours but wake up unrefreshed. Nothing is dramatically wrong, yet nothing feels quite right.
In many Owner Led Companies, the business reflects the owner. When the owner drifts, the business drifts. When the owner is depleted, decision quality falls. When the owner ignores warning signs, the business eventually pays the price. It is the same pattern I see when leaders ignore the early signals in their team or their culture. Small issues compound quietly.
That is why Peter’s work matters. He reframes longevity as a leadership discipline rather than a health project. The question shifts from “How do I avoid decline” to “How do I design a body and mind that can lead well for decades”.
His structure is simple. Exercise. Nutrition. Habits. Mindset. Social connection. What struck me is how small the gap is between doing nothing and doing something. Moving from almost no activity to sixty minutes a week can reduce major mortality risk by around twenty five per cent. At one hundred and fifty minutes, the reduction approaches forty per cent. There is no investment in your business that produces that kind of return.
Peter talks about three anchors. Sweat a little. Build some strength. Maintain flexibility. None of this needs to become a new full time job. It fits into the margins of daily life. Walk further. Take the stairs. Choose the café that is not under your building. Build a few habits that your future self will thank you for.
Nutrition is the same. Less beige on the plate. More colour. Better choices when travelling. Habits and mindset matter just as much. The people who age well stay curious, protect sleep and maintain the relationships that keep them grounded. They challenge themselves. They avoid perfection and focus on consistency.
For me, this all comes back to something I wrote in Made to Thrive. Leaders must understand how to succeed in the role. That applies to leading your business, and it applies to leading your body. Most CEOs are capable of succeeding. Most want to succeed. What is missing is understanding. Not knowledge. Understanding. What to do. Why it matters. And how to build a routine that lasts.
Your health span is not fixed. It is shaped by the decisions you make long before you feel the cost of drifting. The business needs you sharp. Your family needs you present. And your future self needs you to take this seriously now, while small changes still make a compounding difference.
If you want to go deeper, my conversation with Peter explores the science behind ageing, the habits that matter most and the simple actions busy executives can start today without turning their life upside down.
You can listen to the full episode on this week’s Evolution Partners Podcast.
The Evolution Partners Podcast
E79 |The Healthy Hundred with Dr Peter Larkins
If you want to stay sharp, energetic and high-performing well into your later decades, you need to deliberately invest in your healthspan, not just your lifespan. Sport and exercise physician Dr Peter Larkins is a former Olympic middle-distance runner and one of the pioneers of sports medicine in Australia. Across his career, Peter has worked with elite athletes, AFL clubs, national teams and major media networks.
Peter breaks down the five pillars of healthy longevity, the real-world benefits of movement and strength training, how to eat well on the road, the role of sleep and mindset, and what the most successful leaders who age well all have in common.
Takeaways:
- Healthy longevity comes from deliberately investing in your healthspan, not just your lifespan.
- Movement is medicine, and even small amounts of consistent activity dramatically improve long-term health.
- Strength training delivers powerful metabolic benefits far beyond simply building bigger, stronger muscles.
- Sleep is critical recovery, directly influencing energy, cognition, mood and daily performance capacity.
- Nutrition works best when your plate is colourful, simple and mostly plant-focused each day.
- High-performing leaders who age well share drive, mindset discipline and consistent personal health habits.
- Incidental activity – stairs, walking, standing – adds meaningful benefits for time-poor entrepreneurs and executives.
- A balanced approach, not extreme protocols, creates sustainable wellbeing and long-term high performance.
The Evolution Partners is a weekly podcast hosted by Brad Giles. Join Brad as he engages in conversations with some of the world’s sharpest minds, learning a bit more about them and delving into what makes them tick.
Watch on YouTube:



