Should You Give Your Leadership Team Equity In Your Business?
It usually starts with a good instinct. Your General Manager has been with you seven years. They’ve carried more than the role asked for, they’ve turned down at least one approach you know about, and you’ve started to worry about what happens if they go. So you begin thinking about equity.
Then you ask around, or you search, and everything you find is written for a technology start-up in its third year. Vesting cliffs, option pools, dilution tables, a cap table heading toward a raise. None of it sounds like your business, and you can’t work out whether that’s because the advice doesn’t apply or because you’re behind.
It’s the first one. And the gap matters more than it looks, because the standard advice was designed for an owner whose intent is the opposite of yours.
The short answer
Whether you should give your leadership team equity depends on what you’re building the business toward, not on how big it is or how good the person is. The three most common endgames for an Owner Led Company point to three different instruments, and copying the structure designed for a different endgame is where the damage gets done.
| Your endgame | Usual instrument | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Sell, list or recapitalise | Employee Share Option Plan | The reward is tied to the event you're both working toward, and options are the structure the Australian rules leave open to a leadership team on its own |
| Keep it in the family, no outside parties | Phantom equity or a long-term cash plan | Real equity creates a shareholder you can't remove, with a claim on profits and a say in decisions you intended to make yourself |
| Hand it to someone already inside the business | Ordinary shares, bought through a staged buy-in | Equity is the transaction rather than the incentive, so it needs a purchase pathway at an agreed valuation, not a grant |
If you don’t yet know which row you’re in, that’s the work to do first. Everything below changes depending on the answer.
Why owners reach for equity, and when it’s the right call
Give the instinct its due, because it’s often sound.
Equity does things a bonus can’t. It changes how someone weighs a decision whose payoff lands years after the current financial year, which is most of the decisions that matter. It makes the difference between an employee who’s paid well to run your business and a person who owns part of what they’re building. When it’s the right instrument, nothing substitutes for it.
There are real cases where it’s the answer:
- You’re competing for people who have other options. If the person you want could take a role at a firm ten times your size, salary alone won’t hold them, and equity is the only lever with enough weight.
- The person is a genuine co-builder. Not an excellent employee, but someone whose judgement has shaped what the company became. Withholding equity from that person is its own kind of error.
Where it goes wrong is when equity is reached for as a retention fix, without the owner having answered a prior question.
What are you optimising for?
I asked Allan Dib, author of The 1-Page Marketing Plan and Lean Marketing, how he defines a better business when he came on The Evolution Partners Podcast. His answer is one I quoted in Bigger isn’t Better, Better is Better
“A better business begins with the owner, who must answer the question ‘what am I optimising for, what is the outcome I want?'”
That question governs the equity decision, and most owners try to answer the equity question first.
Bo Burlingham gave the same idea a structure. He’s the former executive editor of Inc. magazine and the author of Small Giants, which documented companies that chose to be great rather than big, and I’ve had him on The Evolution Partners Podcast. In his later book Finish Big: How Great Entrepreneurs Exit Their Companies on Top, he sets out four stages of an exit: exploratory, strategic, execution and transition.
Two of those matter here. Stage one, exploratory, is the introspective work, investigating the possibilities and deciding what you do and don’t care about. Stage three, execution, is where you actually do the deal, and his list of possible deals includes a sale to a third party, a management buyout and a gift to your children. Stages two and four sit either side and aren’t where this decision gets made.
His finding, drawn from dozens of owner interviews, is that people who finish well did the stage one work early, and the ones who look back on it as a nightmare were usually forced into it having given it little prior thought.
Granting equity is a stage three decision. Those three deals are three different destinations, and an owner who grants equity before doing the stage one work is executing toward a destination they haven’t chosen.
Three endgames account for the majority of Owner Led Companies I work with, and each points somewhere different.
Endgame one: scale toward a liquidity event. You intend to sell, list or recapitalise, and you’re competing for talent that has alternatives. An Employee Share Option Plan is a natural fit here, because the reward is tied to the event you’re both working toward. This is the only endgame the standard Australian literature is actually written for.
Endgame two: a family business with no outside parties. You want the business to be owned by your family in twenty years. In that case, equity is usually the wrong instrument, and the reason isn’t tax or dilution. It’s that you’ve created a shareholder you can’t remove, with a claim on profits and a say in decisions you intended to make yourself. Nothing about that is a problem in year one. It becomes one somewhere in the middle of those twenty years, when the relationship has changed and the shares haven’t.
This is also the endgame with the least written about it. Burlingham says in his introduction that he deliberately set aside the succession challenges family businesses face when ownership passes between generations, on the basis that it’s covered elsewhere. For an Australian family business weighing whether to bring a non-family executive onto the share register, it isn’t covered well anywhere, and the tax rules below make the decision harder than it first appears.
Endgame three: internal succession. Somebody in the business will eventually buy it. Then equity is the point of the exercise, and a small incentive grant is the wrong shape entirely. What’s needed is a staged buy-in with an agreed valuation methodology, not a reward for last year’s performance.
Work out which of those you’re in before you look at a single structure. Almost everything that follows changes depending on the answer.
Can an established Australian private company use the ESS start-up concession?
An established Australian private company almost certainly can’t use the ESS start-up concession, and this is the point where most owners discover the advice they’ve been reading doesn’t apply to them.
The Employee Share Scheme start-up concession is the arrangement that makes equity so attractive for start-ups, because there’s no income tax at grant and the employee is taxed under the capital gains rules when they sell. To use it, the company must satisfy all of the following at the time of the offer:
- Unlisted, with no company in the group quoted on a stock exchange
- Every company in the group incorporated less than 10 years ago
- Aggregated group-wide turnover under $50 million in the income year before the offer
- An Australian resident company
There are conditions on the employee too. Immediately after acquiring the interest they can’t hold more than 10 per cent of the shares or control more than 10 per cent of the voting power. Shares must be offered at a discount no greater than 15 per cent of market value.
Options must carry an exercise price at or above the market value of an ordinary share at grant. A minimum three-year disposal restriction applies.
Eligibility is assessed at each grant. Interests granted while you qualified stay covered, but once the company turns ten, passes $50 million or lists, the concession isn’t available for new offers. It doesn’t come back.
What tax concessions are available to a private company that isn’t a start-up?
A private company that isn’t a start-up can still use a tax-deferred scheme, and there’s a condition inside it that decides whether your plan is possible at all.
Under a tax-deferred scheme the employee is assessed in the year the deferred taxing point occurs rather than the year they acquire the interest. The amount assessed is the market value at that point, less whatever they paid for the interest.
There are three ways into deferral: a real risk of forfeiting the interest, a salary-sacrifice arrangement, or a genuine restriction on disposing of it. The forfeiture route is the one that matters for a leadership team plan. The ATO accepts that a real risk of forfeiture exists where the minimum term of employment is at least six months, so a genuine vesting condition does the work.
Here’s the part that catches owners out:
- If the interests are shares, at least 75 per cent of your Australian-resident permanent employees with at least three years’ service must be, or have been, entitled to acquire ESS interests in the company. A plan that hands shares to five people on the leadership team and nobody else fails that test.
- If the interests are rights, that condition doesn’t apply.
The distinction sits in section 83A-105 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. Where the interest is a right to acquire a share, the provision doesn’t invoke the 75 per cent broad-availability condition in subsection 83A-105(2), and the Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill that introduced the rules states plainly that the requirement doesn’t apply to schemes offering only rights rather than shares.
This is the single biggest reason an Employee Share Option Plan, rather than a direct share issue, is the workable structure for a leadership-team-only arrangement in an established Australian private company. It isn’t a preference. It’s what the rules leave open.
The salary-sacrifice route is the other one owners ask about. It caps out at $5,000 of shares per employee per year and carries the same 75 per cent condition, which puts it outside what a leadership team incentive is trying to do.
What happens to an executive’s equity when they leave?
What happens to an executive’s equity when they leave changed in 2022, in a way owners of private companies should understand before they grant anything.
Until then, leaving was itself a taxing point. An employee who resigned had to pay tax on their shares at that moment, whether or not there was any way to sell them and fund the bill. In a private company there usually isn’t, so departure tended to force a resolution.
Parliament repealed that rule in Schedule 10 of the Corporate Collective Investment Vehicle Framework and Other Measures Act 2022, which received Royal Assent on 22 February 2022. The amendment removed subsection 83A-115(5) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, and it applies where the deferred taxing point occurs on or after 1 July 2022, to interests already on foot as well as new ones. The ATO summarises the change here.
That’s good policy for the employee, and it creates a situation an owner needs to think through. A vested interest held by someone who has left your business is now capable of sitting there, deferred, for a long time. The maximum deferral is 15 years from acquisition, up from seven years for interests acquired before 1 July 2015.
Unvested interests are usually forfeited on departure and vested ones usually aren’t, but that’s determined by the terms you write, not by the tax rules. The mechanism is a set of leaver provisions: rules that say what happens depending on how someone goes, so a resignation on good terms and a dismissal for cause produce different outcomes, and the company has a right to buy the interest back either way. Those belong in the plan documents from the beginning rather than being negotiated with a former executive who already holds part of your company.
What does an employee share scheme cost to run in a private company?
Running an employee share scheme in a private company costs more than the legal fee, and the ongoing part is what gets underestimated.
- Valuation. A private company has no share price, and you still need a defensible market value. Under the start-up concession the exercise price has to be at or above market value at grant. Under a tax-deferred scheme the valuation drives the discount at grant and the amount assessed at the deferred taxing point. Either way it has to be produced, and repeated at each grant round.
- Documentation. Plan rules, offer documents, and terms covering vesting, forfeiture, leavers and buy-back.
- Reporting. ESS statements go to participating employees by 14 July, and the ESS annual report goes to the ATO by 14 August.
- The 30-day rule. If an employee disposes of an interest within 30 days after the deferred taxing point, the taxing point becomes the date of disposal, which can shift the reporting across income years and require amended statements.
None of that is prohibitive. It is a permanent administrative commitment, and an owner should price it in before deciding, not afterwards.
Comparing the instruments
| Ordinary shares | Options or rights (ESOP) | Phantom equity | Long-term cash plan | Profit share | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Available to an established private company | Yes, but the 75 per cent condition blocks a leadership-team-only deferral | Yes, no 75 per cent condition on the forfeiture route | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Suits which endgame | Internal succession | Scale toward a liquidity event | Family business | Family business | Any |
| Cost to the business | Dilution, permanent | Dilution on exercise | Cash at the trigger event | Cash at vesting | Cash annually |
| Requires share valuation | Yes, at each grant | Yes, at each grant | Yes, at each measurement | No | No |
| Creates a shareholder you can't remove | Yes | Yes, once exercised | No | No | No |
| Time to payoff | Immediate ownership | At exercise or exit | At the agreed trigger | Typically 3 to 5 years | Annual |
| Changes long-horizon behaviour | Strongly | Strongly | Moderately | Moderately | Weakly |
The pattern worth noticing is in the last two rows. The instruments that genuinely change how someone weighs a long-horizon decision are the ones that also create a permanent claim on your business. Instruments that avoid the permanent claim buy less behaviour change. No structure gives you one without the other, and the trade-off is the decision.
Where these plans get diluted, and what breaks
Four failures account for most of the damage I see, and the first is the worst.
The promise that was never documented. An owner tells a key person, in a good moment, that they’ll be looked after, that there’ll be equity, that they’ll own a piece of this one day. Nothing is written. Years pass. The conversation is remembered precisely by one party and approximately by the other.
When that promise isn’t delivered, you’ve done far more harm than if you’d never made it. The employee doesn’t forget. They can’t. Every subsequent decision you make gets read through it, and the trust doesn’t come back. If you aren’t prepared to document it, don’t say it.
The grant too small to change anything. Half a per cent of a business the employee can’t value, can’t sell and can’t influence. It costs you dilution and buys no behaviour change, because the recipient can’t work out what it’s worth and eventually stops thinking about it.
The vesting schedule shorter than the strategy. A three-year vest attached to a decision that takes seven years to prove itself rewards the person for being present, not for being right. You’ve paid for tenure and told yourself you bought judgement.
No leaver provisions. The plan is written for the good years. Then someone leaves badly, or a marriage ends, or an estate is administered, and the terms that would have resolved it were never written. Since July 2022 the tax rules no longer force a resolution on departure, so your documents are the only thing that will.
What to do before you reach for equity
If the honest reason you’re considering equity is that you’re worried someone will leave, deal with that on its own terms first, because equity is a poor retention instrument and an expensive one.
In Bigger isn’t Better, Better is Better I set out what actually holds A players. They need three things: a deep sense of purpose, understanding why their work matters, clear direction, knowing where things are headed, and visible progress, seeing the impact of their contributions.
When those break down, people leave regardless of what they hold. As I put it in the book, A players are often willing to trade short-term financial gain for long-term growth and impact, but their patience isn’t unlimited.
So before the structure conversation:
- Check your attrition rate against 15 per cent. In the 15-15-15 model, annual employee attrition above 15 per cent points to a cultural or leadership problem, not a compensation problem. Fix the cause before you buy your way around it.
- Ask why they’d be right to leave. When an A player resigns, the useful question isn’t why they’re wrong. It’s why they’re right, because the answer is where the improvement is.
- Get the role clear enough to succeed in. If somebody isn’t sure what winning looks like in their seat, equity won’t clarify it. The Capable, Understand, Want assessment is where I’d start.
- Confirm you’ve actually built the team. If the leadership team is still forming, this decision is early. When is it time to build a leadership team? covers the sequencing.
Then, if the answer is still equity, you’ll be granting it for the right reason and to a person who was going to stay anyway. That’s the only condition under which it works.
The decision underneath the decision
Most of what’s written about employee equity treats it as a structuring problem. It’s a question about what you’re building, arriving in a form that makes it look like a question about tax.
If the person you’re thinking about asked you today what they’d actually own, when they’d own it, and what happens to it if they leave, how much of that could you answer?
If you want a clearer read on whether your business is compounding, and where attrition, growth and profit actually sit against the benchmarks, start with the Compounding Growth Scorecard.
Frequently asked questions
Can I give equity to just one person on my leadership team?
Through options or rights, yes, because the 75 per cent participation condition in subsection 83A-105(2) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 attaches to shares rather than rights. Through a direct share issue with tax deferral, no, unless at least 75 per cent of your Australian-resident permanent employees with three or more years of service are or have been entitled to participate. Other conditions still apply, including a 10 per cent limit on how much of the company any one participant can hold, so confirm the position for your specific structure with your accountant before you offer anything.
Is phantom equity treated as an employee share scheme?
Phantom arrangements pay a cash amount referenced to share value rather than transferring an interest in the company, so they generally sit outside the ESS provisions and are usually taxed as ordinary remuneration when paid. The treatment depends on how the arrangement is drafted, and it’s a question for your tax adviser rather than one to assume.
What happens if my company passes $50 million in turnover after we’ve made grants?
Grants already made while you were eligible for the start-up concession remain covered. Future grants won’t qualify. The same applies once the company passes ten years since incorporation or lists on an exchange. If you’re near a threshold, the timing of a grant round is a real decision.
Does an employee have to pay tax on shares they can’t sell?
Under a taxed-upfront scheme, yes. The discount is included in assessable income in the year the interest is acquired, which in a private company with no market for the shares can produce a tax bill with no way to fund it. Avoiding that outcome is the main reason to structure a scheme as tax-deferred or, where you qualify, under the start-up concession.
Is an Australian ESOP the same as an American ESOP?
No, and the confusion causes real problems. In Australia, ESOP means an Employee Share Option Plan, where employees hold options over shares in the company. In the United States it means an Employee Stock Ownership Plan, a trust that holds shares on behalf of employees and operates under its own retirement plan rules. They’re different instruments with different tax treatment. American articles about setting up an ESOP are describing something that doesn’t exist here in that form.
How much equity is a normal grant for a General Manager in a private company?
There’s no meaningful benchmark, because the answer depends entirely on your endgame. A grant sized for a business heading to sale in four years and a grant sized for a family business intended to stay in the family are answering different questions. Start with the endgame, not with a percentage.
This article is general information and isn’t tax, legal or financial advice. Employee share scheme rules are technical and the treatment turns on your specific circumstances. Confirm your position with your accountant and lawyer before making an offer.
