Stop Solving Every Problem For Your Team, Role Scorecard vs Job Description: The Key To Defining Success & Linear Thinking Is A Risk You Can’t Afford
26 January 2025 Newsletter
“No man will work for your interests, unless they are his own” David Seabury
Hope you’re Thriving!
I’m all back on deck and have enjoyed a productive week. I hope yours has been equally effective.
Stop Solving Every Problem For Your Team
‘Guess Before Give’ is the only coaching method you need.
Here’s the brutal truth: if you’re always the one solving problems, you’re not a leader—you’re a crutch. Entrepreneurs running mid-sized companies must shift gears and start empowering their teams. How? By using the “Guess Before Give” principle—but here’s the twist: this isn’t about your guessing. It’s about getting your team to guess first.
What Is “Guess Before Give”?
Before you dive in with coaching or advice, ask your employee to hypothesise the solution. Let them guess before you give your input. Why? Because ownership and critical thinking don’t come from being told what to do—they come from figuring it out themselves.
How It Works
1. Start With a Question
Instead of providing an answer, ask:
“What do you think is causing this issue?” or
“What do you think we should do?”
This makes them engage their problem-solving skills rather than defaulting to you for answers.
2. Flip the Script: Guess What I’d Say
For an even more powerful approach, challenge their thinking by asking:
“What do you think I’m going to suggest?”
This reframes the conversation and forces them to align their thought process with yours, anticipating your advice rather than passively waiting for it.
3. Refine Their Thinking
If they’re off-track, don’t immediately correct them. Use follow-up questions like:
“Interesting point—how would that play out?” or
“What might the risks be?”
This helps guide them to a better answer without handing it to them.
4. End With Ownership
Once they’ve landed on a solution—or you’ve collaborated to refine it—make them accountable for execution. This reinforces their confidence and independence.
Why It’s a Game-Changer for Mid-Sized Companies
In growing businesses, leaders can’t be the bottleneck. “Guess Before Give” shifts the weight of problem-solving to your team. It’s how you scale decision-making, build leadership capabilities, and foster a culture of ownership.
Final Thought: Stop handing out answers like a vending machine. Challenge your team to guess first. It’s faster in the short term to give solutions—but in the long run, teaching your people to think is the only way to grow.
Action Step: This week, when a team member asks for advice, flip the script. Say, “What’s your take on it?” or, “What do you think I’m going to suggest?” Watch how their mindset shifts.
Role Scorecard vs Job Description: The Key to Defining Success
A job description gets someone in the seat, but a role scorecard ensures they’re set up to succeed—right from the hiring stage through to peak performance. If you’re relying solely on job descriptions, you’re missing the chance to clarify expectations and drive results from day one.
What’s a Job Description?
A job description focuses on tasks and responsibilities. It lists what needs to be done but doesn’t explain how to measure success.
Example: “Manage customer accounts and respond to client inquiries.”
- Strengths: Great for outlining duties and recruiting.
- Weaknesses: Lacks depth in defining priorities, outcomes, or accountability.
What’s a Role Scorecard?
A role scorecard defines outcomes, key responsibilities, and measurable results. It’s not just about describing the role—it’s about providing a blueprint for hiring, onboarding, and long-term success.
Example: “Increase client retention by 15% in the next 12 months. Resolve 95% of client inquiries within 24 hours.”
Key Elements of a Role Scorecard:
- Outcomes: Clear results the role must deliver.
- Competencies: The specific skills, behaviours, and attributes required.
- Key Metrics: Quantifiable goals tied to business objectives.
Why the Role Scorecard Is Essential
A scorecard is equally powerful for hiring and managing performance.
- During Hiring: It provides candidates with clarity on what’s expected and allows you to assess whether they can meet the role’s measurable outcomes.
- For Onboarding and Performance: It aligns new hires to priorities from day one and ensures accountability over time.
Without a scorecard, employees (and candidates) are left guessing about what matters most. With one, they know exactly how to prioritise, succeed, and deliver results that drive your business forward.
Final Thought: Job descriptions help fill seats. Role scorecards define success. If you’re serious about building high-performing teams, make role scorecards the foundation of your process—from hiring to performance reviews.
Do you use role scorecards in your business? If not, what’s stopping you?
Learn more about Role Scorecards in our book Onboarded.
Why Linear Thinking Is A Risk You Can’t Afford
In today’s fast-changing world, linear thinking is no longer enough. Management teams relying on past trends to predict the future are setting themselves up to fail. Disruptive technologies don’t follow a predictable path—they develop slowly until they hit a tipping point of exponential growth.
Salim Ismail, founder of Singularity University, has long championed the need for exponential thinking. He explains that exponential growth often takes decades to gain momentum, but when it accelerates, it changes everything. Consider that today’s smartphones have the computing power of the U.S. government in 1983, or that Google’s driverless cars have logged over 750,000 accident-free miles. These aren’t small improvements—they’re transformative shifts that leave linear thinkers behind.
In his updated book, Exponential Organizations 2.0: The New Playbook for 10x Growth and Impact (available here), Salim introduces key updates to help businesses thrive in this new landscape. The revised edition dives deeper into case studies of companies leveraging exponential strategies to dominate their industries. It also introduces fresh tools and frameworks to align leadership, culture, and operations with the demands of exponential change.
One of the most impactful updates is the focus on leadership agility. The book emphasises that leaders must move beyond traditional playbooks, embracing new strategies to guide their teams through rapid, technology-driven disruption. It’s not just about seeing the future—it’s about preparing for it with bold, measurable goals.
To remain competitive, management teams must look beyond the usual SWOT analysis and incorporate trends into their strategic planning. By regularly identifying Strengths, Weaknesses, and emerging Trends (SWT), organisations can position themselves to anticipate and adapt to exponential change.
The bottom line is clear: exponential thinking isn’t optional—it’s essential. If you want to stay ahead, dive into Exponential Organizations 2.0 and learn how to position your business for 10x growth.
For a closer look at why linear thinking no longer works, check out this article: Exponential Growth vs Linear Thinking in Management Teams.
The Evolution Partners Podcast
E33 | Never Lose A Customer Again with Joey Coleman
Joey Coleman helps companies retain customers and employees using his 100-day methodology. He’s an award-winning speaker and best-selling author, with companies like Whirlpool and Zappos as clients.
Joey talks about the importance of personalised customer experiences to foster loyalty and engagement. He highlights the connection between customer and employee experience, suggesting that both are essential for business success. Joey encourages businesses to focus on small, impactful gestures that make customers feel valued, ultimately enhancing both customer and employee satisfaction. He says that creating remarkable experiences doesn’t require large investments, just intentionality and focus on the human element, making it a rewarding endeavour for everyone.
Takeaways:
- Regular communication and thoughtful gestures leave a lasting impression on customers.
- Reassure customers quickly after a purchase to reduce buyer’s remorse.
- Technology helps big brands create positive moments, but small businesses can too.
- Small, consistent acts of appreciation build emotional connections with customers.
- Acknowledge unique customer behaviours to strengthen relationships and build trust.
- Implementing customer experience improvements starts with focusing on small, actionable steps.
- Build internal alignment with a clear value-focused mission to ensure cohesive efforts.
- A business that truly cares creates lasting connections and advocates for its brand.
The Evolution Partners is a weekly podcast hosted by Brad Giles. Join Brad as he engages in conversations with some of the world’s sharpest minds, learning a bit more about them and delving into what makes them tick.
Watch the episode on YouTube:

