Struggling With Big Decisions? Focus On Your MIQ, Don’t Let Growth Muddle Your Company’s Strategy & Why People Get The Jim Collins Flywheel Wrong
2 February 2025 Newsletter
“Be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and try to love the questions themselves. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer” — Rainer Rilke
It’s been a productive week with a heatwave here. Ugh. It’s also been really interesting reading about the new AI model DeepSeek and how it led to the the biggest one-day loss in US history.
I think what we should really take away from it is to always question assumptions in our own business, and ask if we are optimally utilising technology to achieve the results we want?
Let’s jump into it.
Struggling With Big Decisions? Focus On Your MIQ
We’re bombarded with inputs all day—emails, meetings, problems, and distractions. We’re in an endless cycle of stimulus – reaction – stimulus, leaving no time for deep thinking.
But here’s the kicker: Most of your biggest decisions aren’t made when you’re trying to figure them out. They happen in the background—when your subconscious mind is working while you’re not.
That’s why the key to better decision-making isn’t working harder. It’s feeding your subconscious the right problem to solve.
Enter the Most Important Question (MIQ).
To tap into your subconscious power, you need focus. Not 20 problems. Not 5. Just one—your Most Important Question.
Here’s how you do it:
1. Before bed, write down your MIQ. What’s the one thing you need to answer? Not a list. Just one question.
2. Forget about it and sleep. Let your subconscious get to work. This isn’t about forcing an answer—it’s about creating space for insights.
3. In the morning, reflect on your MIQ. No overthinking. Just check in and move forward with your day.
This isn’t a magic cure – don’t expect to wake up with the answer. But just knowing what the MIQ is at all times will help you find an answer.
This might not work in a crisis—when action is needed urgently. But for strategic, complex decisions, this process allows your brain to process solutions without you consciously forcing it.
So, what’s your Most Important Question right now? Write it down. Sleep on it. Let your subconscious do its job.
Why Many People Can’t Help But Get the Jim Collins Flywheel Wrong
Jim Collins’ Flywheel Effect is one of the most powerful concepts in business—but most people completely misapply it.
They treat it like a checklist:
- Step 1: Build a great team.
- Step 2: Execute a strong strategy.
- Step 3: Get results.
- Step 4: Reinvest and scale.
Logical? Yes. But completely wrong.
The real Flywheel Effect isn’t about ticking off tasks—it’s about momentum.
It’s not “we need to do X” before Y happens.
It’s “we can’t help but” move to the next step because the momentum forces us forward.
How It Actually Works:
- We hire A-players → We can’t help but execute better.
- Execution improves → We can’t help but see better results.
- Results improve → We can’t help but attract better talent.
- Better talent → We can’t help but double down on what’s working.
Momentum isn’t a choice—it’s a consequence. Each step naturally fuels the next. If your flywheel isn’t spinning, stop forcing the next step. Instead, fix the step before it.
Are You Forcing It or Fueling It?
If you’re grinding through each stage of your business like an uphill battle, your flywheel isn’t broken—it’s just missing momentum.
Ask yourself: Is our next move inevitable, or are we forcing it?
Don’t Let Growth Muddle Your Company’s Strategy
This week, I came across an insightful article by Constantinos C. Markides in the Harvard Business Review titled “Don’t Let Growth Muddle Your Company’s Strategy”. It explores the hidden risks businesses face when chasing growth and offers valuable advice on how to expand without undermining what makes a company unique.
From the article:
“It is rarely one big decision that leads to dilution. More often than not, it is a series of many small decisions, taken over a long period, that cumulatively lead to dilution. Since firms evaluate each investment on its own merits at the time they are considering it, individual investments may not appear as too damaging… but it is difficult to assess their cumulative effect, which is the real culprit for the damage.”
The article opens with a compelling example of Edward Jones, a brokerage firm that built its success on targeting conservative investors in rural areas. However, in its pursuit of growth, the company is now expanding into cities and offering services for high-net-worth clients—moves that could dilute its original strategy.
The Growth Trap
Markides revisits the concept of the “growth trap,” a term coined by Michael Porter, which describes how companies can unintentionally erode their differentiation in the pursuit of expansion. While growth is necessary, it’s the gradual accumulation of decisions—rather than one major mistake—that often results in the dilution of a firm’s strategic identity.
One of the key challenges is timing. The benefits of growth are usually visible in the short term, while the risks to strategic differentiation often take years to surface. By the time leaders recognise the damage, it’s often too late to undo it.
A Framework to Avoid Dilution
To combat this, the article offers a practical solution: identify the core and peripheral elements of your strategy. Core elements, such as the customers you target, what you offer them, and how you compete, must remain sacrosanct. Peripheral elements, on the other hand, can be adjusted and innovated to fuel growth without jeopardising the company’s unique positioning.
My Reflections
This advice struck a chord with me because it’s so easy for companies—particularly those experiencing success—to be tempted by shiny new opportunities. I’ve seen firsthand how growth for the sake of growth can derail even the most focused organisations. What I appreciated most about Markides’ approach was the simplicity of his framework: distilling your strategy into a few key principles (the “who-what-how” of your business) that can act as guardrails for decision-making.
It reminded me of the importance of corporate self-awareness—understanding what makes your business special and doubling down on it, even when new opportunities arise.
Key Takeaways
Here are some key lessons from the article:
- Define and Protect Your Core Strategy: Identify the few elements that truly differentiate your business—these should remain untouchable unless a radical change is required.
- Innovate the Periphery: Adapt non-core elements to pursue growth without compromising your unique identity.
- Establish Guardrails for Decisions: Ensure every investment is evaluated against the company’s core strategy to avoid gradual dilution.
- Clarity Empowers Autonomy: When your strategy is clear, it empowers managers to make aligned decisions without constantly seeking top-level approval.
Final Thoughts
The wisdom in this article lies in its timelessness. It’s a reminder that growth, while necessary, is not always an unqualified good. Sustainable growth comes from understanding your strategic DNA and being disciplined about protecting it. As Markides emphasises, companies must know which parts of their strategy are “core” and which are open to experimentation. It’s a deceptively simple concept but one that, if executed well, can safeguard long-term success.
If you’re interested in diving deeper, I recommend giving the full article a read on the Harvard Business Review website here.
Let me know your thoughts—how does your company navigate the tension between growth and preserving its identity?
The Evolution Partners Podcast
E34 | Getting Your People to Step Up with Shivani Gupta
Entrepreneur, business coach, and speaker Shivani Gupta has 30+ years of experience helping businesses thrive by engaging and nurturing talent. Shivani shares her insights on leadership, talent retention, and the importance of fostering a positive workplace culture. She discusses the concept of “Shoshin”, or a beginner’s mindset, and how it can enhance leadership effectiveness.
She also delves into the challenges mid-sized businesses face in retaining key talent and the necessity of viewing employees as assets rather than liabilities. Shivani emphasises the importance of succession planning, effective feedback mechanisms, and coaching frameworks for managers. She concludes by discussing what constitutes a better business and the significance of personal growth through habits.
Takeaways:
- Shoshin encourages leaders to maintain an open and curious mindset.
- Engaging talent is crucial in today’s talent economy.
- Employer branding is essential for attracting top talent.
- Mid-sized companies often struggle with retention due to limited opportunities.
- Viewing employees as assets fosters a positive culture.
- Succession planning helps mitigate the impact of employee turnover.
- Regular feedback enhances employee engagement and retention.
- Coaching managers can empower teams and improve accountability.
- A better business focuses on meaningful growth, not just scale.
- Conducting a time audit can help leaders prioritise effectively.
The Evolution Partners is a weekly podcast hosted by Brad Giles. Join Brad as he engages in conversations with some of the world’s sharpest minds, learning a bit more about them and delving into what makes them tick.

