Why zero-sum thinking kills strategy, 4 elements to build strategic competence in your leadership team & Not every AI tool will make it a year
27 July 2025 Newsletter
“Companies must resist the pressure to expand into every profitable niche because doing so often leads to blurred focus and compromised trade-offs.” Michael Porter
Hope you’re Thriving!
It’s been a productive week with several meetings and recording the audio version of my new book Bigger isn’t Better, Better is Better: Avoiding the endless pursuit of more to build a better business (and life).
We’re aiming for a release in early October and I’m keen to begin sharing ideas and concepts from it with you in the coming months.
Why zero-sum thinking kills strategy
Too many leadership teams see strategy as a fight to the death.
“If our competitor does X, we have to do X too.”
“If they win, we lose.”
“If they lower prices, we have to follow.”
This is zero-sum thinking. And it’s a trap.
Zero-sum competition assumes the market is fixed. That there’s only one race and only one way to win. It leads to imitation, reactive moves, and eventually, a business that relies on price as its only lever.
Once you’re there, it’s a race to the bottom.
A strategy built on matching competitors is not a strategy. It’s survival. And it never ends well.
Michael Porter defined strategy as a unique and valuable position in the market that is different from the competition. Not better. Not faster. Different.
That’s positive-sum thinking. The idea that you win not by copying, but by choosing a different game to play. One that creates value in a way others don’t.
There’s room for more than one winner. But only if you stop trying to win someone else’s race.
Not every AI tool will make it through next year
Right now, AI is having its moment. Vendors are booming. Teams are buying. Leaders are spending.
But much of it isn’t strategic. It’s reactive.
People are spending money without the logic of discipline. Tools are being trialled without clear use cases. Multiple teams are solving the same problem in different ways. The thinking is: just get something in place.
But this time will pass.
We’ve seen it before. A new technology arrives, and before there’s clarity on what works, money flows freely. Everyone’s testing. Everyone’s buying. Then the dust settles. Budgets tighten. Scrutiny returns. And the tools that don’t deliver quietly disappear.
Next year, that shift will come for AI.
If you’re leading a mid-market business, now is the time to get ahead of it. Start reviewing what’s been adopted. Ask where there’s duplication. Identify what’s genuinely improving your business. Cut the rest before someone else asks why it’s still being paid for.
This phase isn’t about doing everything. It’s about learning what’s worth keeping.
The 4 elements to build real strategic competence in your leadership team
In many leadership teams, there are individuals who speak with confidence in strategy discussions. They seem certain. They push hard for their ideas. And they often carry weight in the room.
But perceived confidence is not the same as actual competence in strategic decision-making.
This is one of the most overlooked challenges in leadership teams. A person may look and sound the part, but lack the depth, discipline, and rigour that strategy requires. Others may have the capability but get overshadowed in the noise. Over time, decisions start to lean toward confidence, not competence.
If you want to build a strategy that leads to a unique and valuable position in the market, you need to close that gap. You need to build actual strategic competence across the team.
And that’s not something you achieve with a single workshop or a clever set of questions. It’s a process. One that must develop four key elements over time.
1. Skills
Leaders need the ability to think and act strategically. That includes understanding the competitive landscape, assessing internal capabilities, evaluating risk, and thinking beyond first-order consequences. These are not inherent skills. They have to be learned and developed.
2. Behaviours
Competence also shows up in how people operate. Do they ask the right questions? Do they pause before jumping to conclusions? Do they challenge assumptions and listen carefully to other viewpoints? The way leaders behave in decision-making moments often reveals the true level of competence.
3. Processes
Strategic competence doesn’t grow in a vacuum. It grows through structured processes. External analysis. Internal assessments. Regular planning cycles. Decision reviews. These processes create the space and discipline needed to think well, align, and adjust when necessary.
4. Mindset
Even with the right skills and processes in place, without humility and a growth mindset, nothing changes. Leaders must be willing to learn, to accept feedback, and to shift their thinking when required. Carol Dweck’s research on growth mindset shows that those who believe their abilities can be developed are more likely to improve over time. Competence in strategy depends on the ability to reflect and adapt.
At Evolution Partners, this is the work we do. We help leadership teams move from perceived confidence to actual competence through a structured strategic planning process. One that builds capability slowly and deliberately, quarter by quarter.
If strategic decisions in your business are being made by those who sound the most confident, rather than those best equipped to make them, it’s time to build real competence. And that starts with doing the work.
The Evolution Partners Podcast
E59 | Clear Thinking and Accountability with Mark Green
Mark Green is a globally recognised leadership coach, author and speaker who works with CEOs and executive teams to build accountable, high-performing cultures. Mark shares why fear – whether driven by ego, scarcity or failure – is the biggest hidden blocker to performance and accountability.
He outlines the three elements of accountability, the power of role clarity, and how tolerating underperformance can erode credibility and culture. Mark also explores the transformation that happens when leaders stop trying to be liked and instead focus on being respected. From feedback to core values, he explains how great leaders lead by example – and why empathy, not ego, is the foundation of real leadership.
Takeaways:
- Leaders must confront fear – of ego, scarcity or failure – to unlock their own and others’ potential.
- What a leader tolerates sets the standard for culture, performance and team behaviour.
- Clarity around role outcomes transforms vague expectations into accountability and measurable results.
- Accountability begins with leaders who consistently model the behaviours they expect from their teams.
- Feedback should be frequent, constructive and normalised – not reserved for annual reviews or crisis moments.
- Raising expectations often inspires higher performance, not lower morale, when communicated with purpose and clarity.
- Tolerating toxic high-performers undermines trust, morale and long-term organisational health.
- Course correction through small, regular feedback prevents larger issues and builds a culture of continuous improvement.
The Evolution Partners is a weekly podcast hosted by Brad Giles. Join Brad as he engages in conversations with some of the world’s sharpest minds, learning a bit more about them and delving into what makes them tick.
Watch on YouTube:

